You do not have to bring a date to dinner
Thanksgiving is a week away, and someone at the table is going to ask whether you are seeing anyone. On the Wasatch Front the question often arrives before the rolls do, and it comes back on ordinary Sundays.
You do not owe the room a person. Arriving alone is a normal way to eat with people who already know you, and a new relationship does not become real by sitting through a family meal.
Two studies are worth knowing before you decide who comes with you. One is about whose opinion of a new partner people act on. The other is about what happens to a relationship when the people around it disapprove.
The question is not a deadline
A holiday meal has a date on the calendar, so it is easy to treat it as a date for your love life too. That is how someone you have known for three weeks ends up invited, because arriving with a partner feels like the answer the table wants.
Most of the time the table wants to know how you are. "Not right now" is a complete answer. So is "Yes, and it is new, so not yet." Decide which one is true before you arrive, say it once, and then ask the person who asked about something in their own life.
A friend's opinion moved the choice
Psychologists Brittany Wright and H. Colleen Sinclair built a dating game to see whose opinion counts. In Pulling the strings, published in the journal Personal Relationships in 2012, participants chatted online with two potential dates. They were then shown comments about one of the two, presented as coming from a friend and from a parent. Some saw both approve, some saw both disapprove, and some saw the friend and the parent disagree.
The friend's opinion changed how much participants liked that person. The parent's opinion mattered only for participants who depended on the parent for more resources than they got from the friend. Think of someone still living at home. And when participants chose between the two dates, only the friend's opinion predicted the choice.
That matches how life tends to run once you live on your own. Your parents may meet a new partner at a meal like this one. Your friends hear about the second date the next morning and meet the person on an ordinary Friday. It is also why a named friend intro still carries weight here. The friend who introduced you will hear how it went.
Disapproval does not make love stronger
There is an old idea that pushback from family brings a couple closer. It is called the Romeo and Juliet effect, after a 1972 study in which couples who reported a rise in interference from their parents also reported a rise in love over the same six months.
Sinclair, Wright, and Kristina Hood ran that study again, using the original questions, and published the result in 2014 as Revisiting the Romeo and Juliet effect in the journal Social Psychology. They followed 396 people in relationships, about half of them married, for three to four months. The effect did not appear. People who reported more interference from family and friends reported less love, less trust, and less commitment, and more criticism of their partner.
Approval ran the other way. When people felt that approval of their relationship had grown, and friends' approval most of all, they also reported that the relationship had improved. The authors found the same direction when they pooled 22 studies on the question.
So if the people around you are cool on someone, that is unlikely to be what brings the two of you closer. In this research it went with a relationship that was doing worse.
What the studies cannot tell you
The dating game was a lab exercise, the comments only appeared to come from a friend and a parent, and a chat with a stranger is not a dinner with your family. The second study asked people how much approval they felt, which may differ from what their friends and parents would say, and it followed them for a few months. It also cannot say which came first, because friends may sour on a relationship that is already going badly. Neither study can tell you what your own table will make of a real guest.
Before the dinner
If you are single this year, you are not arriving short of anything. Bring a dish and the one-sentence answer.
If you are seeing someone new, this dinner is a poor first test. In the dating game, the friend's read was the one people acted on, and your friends also know what you are like in an ordinary week. Let them meet the person first, somewhere with less riding on it. Then listen to what they say, and notice the friend who goes quiet.
If you do bring someone, treat it like any other introduction to people who already have opinions. Tell your guest who will be in the room and what the house is like. Tell your family a little about your guest before the door opens, so the first question is not an interview.
Whichever of these is your year, the opinion worth asking for comes from the people who see you between holidays. Ask them plainly what they think of the person you are seeing, and take the answer seriously.
Enjoyed this one? We will tell you when Bloom opens.
We're building something new in Utah. Start with your email; the rest takes twenty seconds.